To paraphrase Billy Zane in “Titanic,” some teams just seem to “make their own luck,” through their given style of play or the skill of their players. But “puck luck” is very much a thing in the NHL: Sometimes teams and players benefit from it, and other times the puck was just bound to hit the crossbar, like that big blue necklace was destined to end up inside the coat pocket of Rose DeWitt Bukater.
This week in the power rankings, a look at good and bad fortune in the NHL.
How we rank: The ESPN hockey editorial staff submits polls ranking teams 1-31, and those results are tabulated to the list featured here. Teams are rated through Tuesday night’s games, taking into account overall record, recent success and other factors such as injuries.
Previous ranking: 1
Cedric Paquette has been a lot of things for the Lightning: grinder, pest, player the French-language media requests during the playoffs for interviews. Now we can add “efficient,” because with a little puck luck he has a 16.7 shooting percentage with 12 goals on 72 shots — by far the best rate of his career.
Previous ranking: 4
Everything’s coming up Joe Pavelski this season, with a career-best 17.2 shooting percentage on 122 even-strength shots. My, it’s almost like it’s a contract year!
Previous ranking: 3
Jake DeBrusk with David Krejci as his center, for 592 even-strength minutes, has a goals-for percentage of 60.53. Without him, in 120 minutes, it’s at 44.44 percent. So, it goes without saying, but we’ll say it anyway: DeBrusk has been lucky to have him.
Previous ranking: 2
A good penalty kill requires skilled players, smart positioning and, yeah, a bounce or two going your way. The Flames have had all of this on their PK, generating 16 short-handed goals, the second highest total for an NHL team in the last decade.
Previous ranking: 5
The Leafs lead the NHL in PDO, a stat that’s a combination of on-ice shooting percentage and save percentage. Their PDO is 1.028, which is the highest they’ve had in the last three seasons. Who had Andreas Johnsson (17.9) having a higher shooting percentage than Auston Matthews (16.8)?
Previous ranking: 6
What if I told you there was a player who had shooting percentages of 17.6 and 18.3 in his first two years in the NHL, but just 13.1 this season? You would probably say that Patrik Laine has been seriously unlucky this season.
Previous ranking: 8
Jakub Vrana‘s 5-on-5 shooting percentage this season is 16.53, best on the Capitals, with 20 goals on 121 shots. Last season on 126 shots, it was 8.73 percent.
Previous ranking: 9
Every season, there’s an unexpected team that’s “riding the PDO train.” While the Islanders’ PDO hasn’t been above unsustainable standards, it stands at 1.025, which is an indication that they’re getting stellar goaltending while also getting a little lucky at the other end.
Previous ranking: 7
Since 2016-17, no Predator has clanged the post more times than Viktor Arvidsson (19), including five times in 47 games this season.
Previous ranking: 10
Jake Guentzel‘s 5-on-5 shooting percentage is 18.54. So, um, thanks Sidney.
Previous ranking: 11
For all the great things the Hurricanes have done this season, a little puck luck would have made it better. Consider they have the most high-danger shot attempts, and yet have the lowest high-danger goals out of the top 11 teams in high-danger attempts.
Previous ranking: 12
The Knights have an actual goal differential of minus-22, a stat that subtracts expected goals from actual goals. One way of looking at this: Vegas is generating a ton of good chances but hasn’t converted enough of them.
Previous ranking: 14
Since Jan. 1, 2016, no player in the NHL has dinged the crossbar more than Vladimir Tarasenko (10 times).
Previous ranking: 15
Tarasenko’s countryman Artemi Panarin has hit the crossbar five times this season. No one on the Jackets has hit it more than once.
Previous ranking: 13
Max Domi has shown offensive spark in the past. But there has to be at least a little puck luck when a player goes from a 3.88 shooting percentage at even strength to a 15.75, which is what he has done this season.
Previous ranking: 17
Tyler Seguin‘s monthly shooting percentages from October through December, at which point his team president called him “horse bleep”: 5.2, 9.4, 6.8. In the two months that followed it: 16.3, 16.4. Guess he was super motivated to stop hitting so many posts and crossbars. Or, and hear me out: He suddenly stopped hitting as many posts and crossbars.
Previous ranking: 20
For a long period this season, the Coyotes were at the bottom of the NHL in shooting percentage. In October, it was at an astounding 1.7 percent. Now? They’re up to 8.5 percent as they rise up the standings. The tide has turned.
Previous ranking: 18
Sean Couturier has seen 71 of his 80 missed shot attempts sail wide. Last season, it was just 66 times on 83 misses.
Previous ranking: 16
Jason Zucker is starting to heat up, with six of his 20 goals this season coming in the last eight games. The puck luck has not been with him, as he has a 10.7 shooting percentage in 69 games. Last season, it was at 14.9 percent, which was pretty great timing for a guy who signed a five-year extension in July.
Previous ranking: 19
The Senators currently have an 18.5 percent chance of winning the draft lottery. OK, that’s not exactly “puck luck,” but we just felt the need to restate this for the benefit of our friends in Colorado.
Previous ranking: 23
If we believe that PDO is a measure of luck, well, the Panthers are a black cat walking under a ladder into a broken mirror: They’re at 0.985, lowest in the NHL at 5-on-5.
Previous ranking: 22
Brandon Saad is tied with Tyler Seguin in hitting the crossbar six times this season, the difference of course being that his team president never called him “horse bleep” for doing so.
Previous ranking: 21
Jeff Skinner has a shooting percentage of 16.1 this season, which would be a new career high. Which, again, seems to happen to these guys in contract years, huh?
Previous ranking: 24
Connor McDavid has 34 goals this season in 65 games. That number could be even higher if he hadn’t hit the goalposts 11 times. Last season, on more shots, he hit it only seven times.
Previous ranking: 25
Nikolay Goldobin has 100 shots on goal. He also has 53 shots that have missed the net, including six that have gone off the post, tied with Jake Virtanen for most on the team.
Previous ranking: 26
Mika Zibanejad is tied with Connor McDavid, having hit the posts with shots 11 times this season.
Previous ranking: 28
The Ducks have allowed 712 shot attempts from high-danger areas but have an .847 high-danger save percentage, fifth best in the NHL.
Previous ranking: 27
While it has been a disastrous season on many levels for the Devils, one bright spot has been Travis Zajac. The 33-year-old center might produce his best goal-scoring season on average, with a career-best 15.1 shooting percentage.
Previous ranking: 29
Jeff Carter hadn’t had a shooting percentage under 9.9 since 2006-07. This season, through 63 games? It’s a putrid 7.1 percent. Two seasons ago, he averaged over three shots per game. This season? It’s at 2.24.
Previous ranking: 30
There has to be some level of horrible “puck luck” to not have scored a goal since Dec. 8, 2018. Right, Justin Abdelkader?
Previous ranking: 31
As you can see on the Left Wing Lock “Pluck” chart, the Senators are like Pluto in the NHL puck luck universe.